• Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop
No Result
View All Result
Mumbaj
  • Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop
No Result
View All Result
Mumbaj
No Result
View All Result
Home Mumbai News

taloja: ‘Is humour banished from jails’ quips Bombay HC bench when told Taloja didn’t have Wodehouse in library | Mumbai News

taloja: ‘Is humour banished from jails’ quips Bombay HC bench when told Taloja didn’t have Wodehouse in library | Mumbai News
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



MUMBAI: The Bombay high court on Tuesday concluded the hearing of activist and Elgar Parishad accused Gautam Navalakha’s plea of house custody on grounds of poor health and jail conditions. The bench of Justices S B Shukre and G A Sanap again in a lighter vein when told by the state lawyer that he was given books available in prison and PG Wodehouse is not in the Taloja library said, “why, humour is banished from prison?”
The state sought to justify that the ‘security’ concerns expressed over the parcel containing the book last year were due to Covid-19 pandemic precautionary concerns as a preventive measure, but the high court on seeing the order in Marathi which only mentioned ‘security’ said it did not give the impression of pandemic precautions.
“you must understand that laymen also understand ‘suraksha’ as security, when it mentions covid reasons then it is precautionary.’’
The State additional public prosecutor Sangeeta Shinde had submitted a fresh affidavit and the HC asked if it explained everything in it with documents annexed and questioned why new explanations were being added orally when court was pointing out contradictions.
The bench, as an aside, asked State, “Do you not have English books in the library?” Shinde said they also “have Urdu books’’ and “spiritual books”. She said there are 2850 books at Taloja prison including Dnyanpeeth Puruskar books and would supply a list. “That is nothing. Even a secondary school will have more books. Anyway that is a different issue,’’ said Justice Shukre.
The State gave a list of books given to Navalakha. The bench noted they included, “Arabian Nights, Ruskin Bond, Ishwar ka Chehra’’.
The bench said jails must have a “wider selection’’ and book in other languages too’’ adding, “It is very important for jail inmates to read books of humour and other books on fiction and spirituality.’’
The National Investigation Agency (NIA) through ASG Anil Singh opposed Navalakha’s plea for house arrest citing the seriousness of the anti-terror Act invoked against him, practical difficulties and that his bail plea on merits was still pending, besides his plea for medical bail and default bail were rejected. Singh said Navalakha would be provided medical treatment as and when needed, as that is his right. Navalakha, 70, who was briefly in house arrest in 2018 in the case before being asked by the Supreme Court to surrender said Singh, despite the jails being overcrowded then too.
Yug Chaudhry counsel for Navalakha, cited an SC order and the law to say house arrest can be given on a case to case basis. The fear of the unknown –of floodgates opening—cannot prevent the court from ordering his house arrest and he pleaded to the Court’s “good conscience and fair play’’ on deciding on costs if any to be borne by the inmate himself.
Singh for NIA said “it is not a fit case for House arrest. It would be difficult for State and Centre to implement it when investigation in ongoing.’’ He said it would open floodgates for similar application as there “are thousands of 70 year old prisons across jail and many who have health issues.’’ He said, “with two police guards to be posted out, will police force be deployed for such case or deal with law and order, crime investigations.’’
Shinde for State said Navalakha refused to go for check up even to Tata Memorial Research hospital which is the best, saying he wished to go to a hospital of his choice and that a report by JJ hospital belied fears over a lump on chest. She also said he is in a high security single occupancy cell. There are 33 such prisoners at Taloja she said when asked by the HC.
Taloja has a capacity of little over 2124 mostly undertrial prisoners, last May had almost 3000 inmates.





Source link

Next Post
HC reserves verdict in Dheeraj Wadhawan’s plea against order to shift him to J J Hospital

HC reserves verdict in Dheeraj Wadhawan’s plea against order to shift him to J J Hospital

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Mumbai Electricity Cut Today Latest News, Thane, Panvel Power Cut Off News Update

Mumbai Electricity Cut Today Latest News, Thane, Panvel Power Cut Off News Update

October 12, 2020
Actor Arya & Actress Sayyeshaa Marriage Function

Actor Arya & Actress Sayyeshaa Marriage Function

February 12, 2021
How to Draw an Indian Temple: One Point Perspective

How to Draw an Indian Temple: One Point Perspective

March 4, 2021
Sumbaran Hot scene – Dialogue Promo | Sumbaran – Marathi Movie | Ashwini Kalsekar

Sumbaran Hot scene – Dialogue Promo | Sumbaran – Marathi Movie | Ashwini Kalsekar

February 5, 2021

Why the 2017 F1 rule changes will not level the playing field

0

Burnley v Lincoln City Betting: Clarets set for more cup joy on home soil

0

Orlando City provides Jason Kreis a chance at redemption – will he take it?

0

Why F1 must fight to restore the Nürburgring to the calendar

0
Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

June 4, 2023
Mumbai News Live Updates: 6-year-old electrocuted after coming into contact with lamp post in Vakola

Mumbai News Live Updates: 6-year-old electrocuted after coming into contact with lamp post in Vakola

June 3, 2023
Maharashtra News Live Updates: 5 booked for producing fake certificates to get police jobs

Maharashtra News Live Updates: 5 booked for producing fake certificates to get police jobs

June 2, 2023
‘Open spaces in Mumbai can’t be left to caretakers’ | Mumbai News

‘Open spaces in Mumbai can’t be left to caretakers’ | Mumbai News

June 1, 2023

Recommended

Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

June 4, 2023
Mumbai News Live Updates: 6-year-old electrocuted after coming into contact with lamp post in Vakola

Mumbai News Live Updates: 6-year-old electrocuted after coming into contact with lamp post in Vakola

June 3, 2023
Maharashtra News Live Updates: 5 booked for producing fake certificates to get police jobs

Maharashtra News Live Updates: 5 booked for producing fake certificates to get police jobs

June 2, 2023
‘Open spaces in Mumbai can’t be left to caretakers’ | Mumbai News

‘Open spaces in Mumbai can’t be left to caretakers’ | Mumbai News

June 1, 2023

Recent

Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

June 4, 2023

Popular

  • Maharashtra News Live Updates: CM Eknath Shinde to launch mega cluster development scheme in Thane

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Categories

  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Tourist Place

@ Copyright 2021 All Rights Reserved FOR SALE: This domain and website is for sale. Please call 360 256-1117 or email thewaymarketing88@gmail.com for all the details.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop

@ Copyright 2021 All Rights Reserved FOR SALE: This domain and website is for sale. Please call 360 256-1117 or email thewaymarketing88@gmail.com for all the details.