• Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop
No Result
View All Result
Mumbaj
  • Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop
No Result
View All Result
Mumbaj
No Result
View All Result
Home Mumbai News

‘Pandemic showed us the criminal justice system’s gaps’

‘Pandemic showed us the criminal justice system’s gaps’
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



WITH OVER 200 Covid-19 cases detected in the state’s prisons over the past month, the Bombay High Court took suo motu cognizance and has been hearing from the state government and other parties on steps that can be taken to decongest the jails.

Sadaf Modak speaks with Dr Vijay Raghavan, project director, Prayas, a field action project of Tata Institute of Social Sciences, which works on prison reform in terms of the present situation and the lessons learnt from the pandemic for the criminal justice system.

Overcrowding has remained a constant feature in our jails. Is there an urgent need to decongest the jails?

The whole objective of the criminal justice system is to rehabilitate and facilitate social re-entry of those who are processed by the system. If that is the main objective, then it is very important that the custodial conditions are decent. The experience of punishment and how one is treated inside jail is linked to their rehabilitation and re-entry into society. There are studies, which show that this experience has a link with reoffending. It is a mandate of a civil society, the constitution, which guarantees the basic right of every person.

India is also a signatory to the UN Standard Minimum Rules for Treatment of Prisoners. It is enshrined in law, so there is a need to ensure that the condition for prisoners are decent, which does not happen in an overcrowded jail. In a pandemic, it becomes even more important to decongest because Covid-19 spreads in close contact and overcrowding is one of the reasons for its spread.

The High Court has been discussing the steps that can be taken to decongest jails. What do you think is a solution to overcrowding in jails?

A state-appointed High-Powered Committee had given guidelines on who can be released last year. Due to a sudden increase in active cases then, there was a push to release prisoners following the Supreme Court’s directions to decongest the jails. In the end, however, it is a judicial decision and an administrative order by the committee cannot override a judicial process.

It made recommendations and trial courts were told to take a decision on release. We are in a pandemic, if these cases are to be decided on merit, many will not be released. Some may not have documents, which are required or may be unable to arrange for cash or surety to be released. The courts were also not functioning with full staff and had staggered timings among judicial officers as well. This led to delay in decisions on bails, in conducting of trials.

While the committee had expected that there will be a release of over 17,500 prisoners, the actual number was around 10,000. Meanwhile, arrests have been taking place leading to an increase in the population again. The Supreme Court has said the Arnesh Kumar judgment should be followed (it said arrests should not be made automatically in cases where punishment is a maximum of seven years or less). I do not know to what extent it has been adhered to.

There were some concerns and apprehensions about the safety of victims and recidivism of those released on temporary bail or emergency parole.

Yes, that is why the final discretion about release is with the courts. Parole too is granted on the basis of certain criteria. A report is called from the local police station to assess if the person being released will be a threat. Even those who were released were mandated to report to the local police station regularly to ensure that no violations take place.

We have seen very a few cases of offences committed by those released. The official rate of recidivism in India is anyway at 6-7 per cent as against over 50 per cent in the West.

A study was conducted by Prayas to assess the pandemic’s impact on criminal justice affected persons and their families. Are existing schemes enough to facilitate re-entry of those released?

The study was in the context of those released during the pandemic. Among our findings was that only 12 per cent continued to earn after being released. Many faced stigma, including some who were not able to go to their villages and find shelter. Some had to walk long distances to get to their homes since lockdown restrictions were in place.

Even in normal situations, rehabilitation is neglected. We should ideally have a separate department for rehabilitation and corrections, not only for prisoners but for women being released from protection homes, children from observation homes or special homes. We have some financial schemes for them but they are not sufficient for the many issues this population faces.

There are no schemes for undertrials, many of whom also face as much social stigma even after they are cleared of all charges. There is no larger debate or public concern for them as people see them as those having offended society.

Are there lessons from the pandemic for the criminal justice system?

Yes, the pandemic has shown us where the gaps are, it has shown us ways of doing things better. For instance, our bail system focuses on a payment of cash or arranging of a surety to secure bail for an undertrial. This makes it difficult for many to secure bail. Instead of being a finance-dependent system, it could have been one based on risk assessment.

Over 8,000 undertrials were released last year to decongest jails. A very small percentage has reoffended. This shows that they were not a threat to society. They would not have been released in normal situations but one should understand that they are innocent until proven guilty.

Also, we are callous about filling vacancies. There has been a tremendous load on those in the criminal justice system including the prison staff, some of whom lost their lives due to Covid-19. They worked round the clock, what about their mental health too? If they are not well taken care of, they are likely to take it out on prisoners.




Source link

Next Post
Maharashtra: In a first in 30 days, daily cases fall below 50,000 | Mumbai News

Maharashtra: In a first in 30 days, daily cases fall below 50,000 | Mumbai News

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Mumbai Electricity Cut Today Latest News, Thane, Panvel Power Cut Off News Update

Mumbai Electricity Cut Today Latest News, Thane, Panvel Power Cut Off News Update

October 12, 2020
Actor Arya & Actress Sayyeshaa Marriage Function

Actor Arya & Actress Sayyeshaa Marriage Function

February 12, 2021
How to Draw an Indian Temple: One Point Perspective

How to Draw an Indian Temple: One Point Perspective

March 4, 2021
Shakti Mohan Finally Accepts Raghav Juyal As Her BF In A Funny Way On Dance Plus Season 4

Shakti Mohan Finally Accepts Raghav Juyal As Her BF In A Funny Way On Dance Plus Season 4

December 25, 2020

Why the 2017 F1 rule changes will not level the playing field

0

Burnley v Lincoln City Betting: Clarets set for more cup joy on home soil

0

Orlando City provides Jason Kreis a chance at redemption – will he take it?

0

Why F1 must fight to restore the Nürburgring to the calendar

0
Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

February 4, 2023
High price of gold propels sellers and buyers alike in Mumbai | Mumbai News

High price of gold propels sellers and buyers alike in Mumbai | Mumbai News

February 3, 2023
Mumbai’s Gowardhan raises cow milk price by Rs 2 per litre, second hike in a month | Mumbai News

Mumbai’s Gowardhan raises cow milk price by Rs 2 per litre, second hike in a month | Mumbai News

February 2, 2023
Mumbai records three times worse air quality than Delhi | Mumbai News

Mumbai records three times worse air quality than Delhi | Mumbai News

February 1, 2023

Recommended

Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

February 4, 2023
High price of gold propels sellers and buyers alike in Mumbai | Mumbai News

High price of gold propels sellers and buyers alike in Mumbai | Mumbai News

February 3, 2023
Mumbai’s Gowardhan raises cow milk price by Rs 2 per litre, second hike in a month | Mumbai News

Mumbai’s Gowardhan raises cow milk price by Rs 2 per litre, second hike in a month | Mumbai News

February 2, 2023
Mumbai records three times worse air quality than Delhi | Mumbai News

Mumbai records three times worse air quality than Delhi | Mumbai News

February 1, 2023

Recent

Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

February 4, 2023

Popular

  • Gutkha worth Rs 25 lakh seized in Mumbai, 9 held | Mumbai News

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Categories

  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Tourist Place

@ Copyright 2021 All Rights Reserved FOR SALE: This domain and website is for sale. Please call 360 256-1117 or email thewaymarketing88@gmail.com for all the details.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Tourist Place
  • Tourist Hotels
  • Mumbai Temples
  • Mumbai Food
  • Mumbai News
  • Shop

@ Copyright 2021 All Rights Reserved FOR SALE: This domain and website is for sale. Please call 360 256-1117 or email thewaymarketing88@gmail.com for all the details.